44 Google faces renewed uncertainty over a €1.49 billion European antitrust fine after an adviser to the European Union’s highest court recommended overturning the judgment that cancelled the penalty in 2024. The recommendation, issued on November 12, has not reinstated the fine, but it has reopened an important question about how regulators assess restrictions in digital advertising contracts. The dispute dates to a European Commission decision in 2019 concerning Google’s AdSense for Search service. Regulators examined agreements with third-party websites that displayed search advertisements and concluded that contractual restrictions had limited opportunities for rival advertising providers between 2006 and 2016. Those arrangements included exclusivity requirements, restrictions on the placement of competing advertisements, and provisions requiring Google’s approval for certain changes. Google removed the disputed contractual provisions in 2016. In September 2024, the EU’s General Court annulled the penalty. The court found shortcomings in how regulators had assessed relevant circumstances, including the duration of the agreements. The Commission appealed that judgment, keeping the case alive. Advocate General Juliane Kokott has now argued that the lower court applied excessively demanding requirements when examining the potential competitive effects of the restrictions. Her recommendation is that the Court of Justice set aside the earlier judgment and return the case to the General Court for further consideration. The distinction matters. An advocate general’s opinion can influence the court, but it is not binding. Even if the higher court follows the recommendation, the original fine would not automatically become payable in full. The opinion also acknowledges that the eventual penalty may need to be reduced. The case concerns an older search-advertising product, not the same technology at issue in Google’s more recent American advertising-technology litigation. Both proceedings nevertheless concern the degree of control a large platform may exercise over intermediaries and the businesses that depend on them. For publishers, contract terms can determine whether competing advertising services have a practical chance to win business. For advertisers, greater competition may eventually affect choice and transparency, although any commercial benefit remains uncertain. And while a final European ruling is still awaited, the broader lesson from this decade-long dispute is that competition rules can reshape advertising markets long after the original business practices have ended. You Might Be Interested In Reddit expands Shopify integration globally AI fuels ad revenue growth for Meta and Google Sports marketing in India finds its next growth screen in CTV OpenAI lowers GPT-5.6 Sol API costs for developers Bluefish raises $43M to help brands appear in AI search like ChatGPT Google Expands AI-Powered Checkout to Canadian Retailers