Cool Campaigns, Flat Sales: Booze Marketing’s Reckoning

141

After years of flashy campaigns and faddish launches, the drinks industry is finally waking up to what really drives performance—consumer data.

Alcohol marketing once thrived on charm and cultural cachet. But after a decade of chasing trends—from craft gin to hard seltzers—the big booze industry is learning a hard truth: cool doesn’t always convert.

Andrew Tindall, a seasoned marketer who’s worked with Bacardi, Diageo, and Brown-Forman, argues the sector has become lost in its own hype. Too many campaigns, he says, are crafted for industry peers rather than actual consumers. A drinks-marketing echo chamber—what he wryly calls the “DMW” (drink-marketing-wanker) effect—has warped priorities. The result: cluttered launches, gimmicky rebrands, and a near-mythic obsession with “hidden bars” that barely move the sales needle.

But change is brewing. A new generation of marketers is beginning to course-correct by grounding decisions in behavioural data, not bar gossip. That means shifting focus from insider cool to broader, measurable outcomes—such as repeat purchase rates and brand equity growth in core demographics.

The drinks industry’s recent stumbles echo a broader pattern across consumer marketing: style over substance eventually collapses under its own weight. What once dazzled—like quirky craft packaging or influencer-fuelled launches—is now scrutinized for ROI. And rightly so. As investor pressure intensifies and consumer habits fragment, alcohol brands can’t afford to confuse cultural relevance with commercial success.

If the industry is to regain its fizz, it must let go of the vanity metrics and return to what marketing, at its core, is meant to do: drive value by meeting real demand.