Google Revamps Click-Based Business Model

55

After years of organizing the world’s knowledge into neatly presented search results infused with advertising, Google, the leader in search engines, is embarking on a new transformation powered by generative AI.

This AI will provide answers directly to search queries, potentially replacing the need for multiple clicks. It will offer neat summaries and comprehensive explanations of complex tasks, delivering these directly through the Google Search bar.

However, this AI-powered shift could disrupt the click-based, ad-supported business model that has cemented Google’s dominance. The new format features an AI overview followed by sponsored ads, overshadowing the traditional ten blue organic links and the sponsored links that have been the cornerstone of Google’s search advertising.

“Not only is it unclear how ads will look and perform in the new layout, it’s a foregone conclusion that consumers will be less likely to click through to view source material,” said Evelyn Mitchell-Wolf, a senior analyst at eMarketer.

Google has been gradually introducing its zero-click capabilities by expanding its search modules with information boxes from various sources like Wikipedia, weather updates, maps, and more. With AI-driven summaries, users who might have previously clicked through to other websites may now end their search journey within Google’s modules, further reducing attention to sponsored links.

This evolution also complicates the measurement of ad effectiveness. Without clicks as a reliable indicator, it becomes challenging to gauge whether a consumer notices an ad or if the ad influences a purchase decision. “Without clicks as a reliable signal, it’ll be hard to tell whether a consumer notices an ad, much less whether the ad influences a purchase decision,” Mitchell-Wolf added.

In this new AI-powered conversational search paradigm, traditional measures of engagement, like clicks, may become obsolete. Marketers will need to find new ways to measure ad effectiveness.

Despite these challenges, AI-powered search could open new revenue opportunities by monetizing user attention in innovative ways. Google can leverage its array of platforms to introduce new AI services, test their performance, and experiment with different advertising formats.

Google maintains that its evolving search products will continue to drive valuable traffic to content creators and merchants. Initial findings suggest that users who click on links from AI overviews tend to spend more time on those sites, although this may offer little consolation to businesses experiencing a drop in clicks.

Google has incentives to preserve the ad-supported search model. If fewer websites can generate high-quality content due to unreliable ad revenue, the quality of Google’s search results will decline. However, any changes to how Google surfaces content could significantly impact individual websites and businesses reliant on Search.

Lily Ray, vice president of SEO strategy & research at Amsive, noted in a recent analysis that some sites, like Reddit and Amazon, benefitted from Google’s March updates to Search. Google can both take away and give back.

For Google and its stakeholders, the goal is not to jeopardize its search dominance but to adapt it for a future where the concept of web search continues to evolve.