Thursday, November 7, 2024
English English French Spanish Italian Korean Japanese Russian Hindi Chinese (Simplified)

U.S. District Judge Robert Lasnik, who has served on the federal bench in Seattle for more than 25 years, recently issued a firm reminder about the importance of concise legal writing. In a ruling on Monday, Judge Lasnik denied Amazon’s request to file an exceptionally lengthy summary judgment document in a consumer class action lawsuit. The case accuses Amazon of illegally monitoring and collecting user communications through its Alexa and Echo devices, in violation of several states’ wiretap laws.

Judge Lasnik, drawing from his extensive experience, noted that longer legal submissions do not necessarily equate to better or more thorough arguments. “Such expansive submissions are often verbose, repetitive, and a waste of party and judicial resources,” he wrote in his order. This sentiment reflects his belief that excessive length in legal documents often hinders rather than helps the court’s ability to deliver justice efficiently.

Amazon had sought permission to file a document containing 42,000 words, which would amount to about 120 pages. This was the second time Amazon requested an extended page limit after Judge Lasnik initially allowed a brief of 16,800 words, approximately 48 pages. In his order, Judge Lasnik dismissed the notion that Amazon required such an extensive submission, comparing the 120-page request to a “novella,” far exceeding the standard length of most substantive briefs in his district, which are typically no more than 24 pages.

This decision highlights the various procedural rules that attorneys must navigate in both state and federal courts, including guidelines on page limits, the use of acronyms, footnotes, and even the choice of font size and style. Judge Lasnik’s ruling serves as a reminder that adherence to these rules is critical for the efficient functioning of the legal system.

The case against Amazon, filed in 2021, alleges that the tech giant violated wiretap laws by improperly collecting and storing data from its Alexa voice-assistant software. The plaintiffs in the case are seeking billions of dollars in damages, while Amazon has consistently denied any wrongdoing. The company argued that it was “impossible” to make its arguments within the 16,800-word limit, particularly given the need to address circumstances involving ten individual plaintiffs. Amazon claimed that it would suffer “significant unfair prejudice” if not allowed to fully defend its flagship service, Alexa.

Despite these arguments, the plaintiffs’ attorneys from the firms Labaton Sucharow and Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd urged Judge Lasnik to reject Amazon’s request for additional pages, citing concerns over judicial efficiency. Judge Lasnik agreed, stating that allowing Amazon to file a 120-page document would place an undue burden on the court and drain judicial resources.

This ruling is consistent with Judge Lasnik’s long-standing approach to case management, emphasizing clarity and brevity in legal proceedings. Before his appointment to the federal bench in 1998, Judge Lasnik served as a judge in Washington state courts. Over the years, he has garnered attention not only for his legal acumen but also for his occasional references to the lyrics of singer-songwriter Bob Dylan in his rulings.

As the case against Amazon progresses, the decision to enforce strict page limits serves as a reminder that in the legal arena, quality and conciseness often outweigh sheer volume. Both parties now face the challenge of presenting their arguments within the constraints set by the court, ensuring that the case proceeds efficiently while respecting the court’s resources.

Subscribe

* indicates required

The Enterprise is an online business news portal that offers extensive reportage of corporate, economic, financial, market, and technology news from around the world. Visit to explore daily national, international & business news, track market movements, and read succinct coverage of significant events. The Enterprise is also your reach vehicle to connect with, and read about senior business executives.

Address: 150th Ct NE, Redmond, WA 98052-4166

©2024 The Enterprise – All Right Reserved.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept